Monthly Subscription
Cookie of the
Month ClubMonth
Every month: six freshly baked, 100% gluten-free cookies — all one exclusive, limited edition flavor you won't find anywhere else.
$30 / month
What You Get
Every Month, Something New
Six Fresh Cookies
Each month you get six generously sized, fresh baked cookies - individually wrapped and ready for your consumption.
One Flavor, All Six
Molly handcrafts one brand-new, limited edition gluten-free flavor each month. These feature seasonal flavors and local ingredients.
Monthly Reveal
The flavor is kept secret until reveal day. Watch the countdown — then see what's in your box!
Member Reorder Discount
Active members can reorder any past featured flavor or premium flavor anytime — at an exclusive member price, below regular menu pricing.
Pickup Only
Your pickup window is announced by the 15th of each month. No shipping — just fresh, same-day pickup.
Join the Club
$30/month · Cancel anytime
This month's boxes are already being prepared. Subscribe now and your first box will arrive next month — you'll be charged $30 on the 1st, then on the 1st of each month after that. All orders must be picked up within 2 weeks of the ready announcement.
This Month's Flavor
September 2026
Featured Flavor
Lunchbox PB&J
A thick peanut butter cookie rolled in crispy buttery toast crumbs, packed with peanut pieces, stuffed with peanut butter buttercream, and a little packet of homemade Concord grape jam tucked in for later. Drizzle the jam right before you eat. It’s the sandwich you used to find in your lunchbox — just gluten-free, and a lot more fun.
Past Editions
Flavors We've Featured
July 2026
Campfire S’more
June 2026
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
March 2026
Carrot Cake
April 2026
Butterfetti Bliss
May 2026
Brown Butter Tiramisu
July 2026
Campfire S’more
June 2026
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
March 2026
Carrot Cake
April 2026
Butterfetti Bliss
May 2026
Brown Butter Tiramisu
Next month's flavor is a secret — subscribe to find out!
Member Perk
Reorder Your Favorites & Save
Active Cookie Club members can reorder any past featured flavor or premium menu flavor anytime — at an exclusive member discount. Sold in 6-cookie packs.
Premium Menu Flavors
Toasted Salted Toffee
$3.50/cookie member · $4.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKVanilla Bean Sugar
$3.50/cookie member · $4.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKChocolate Chip
$3.50/cookie member · $4.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKTriple Chocolate Fudge
$3.50/cookie member · $4.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKFluffer Nutter
$3.50/cookie member · $4.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKMarshmallow Potato Chip
$3.50/cookie member · $4.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKBirthday Cake
$3.50/cookie member · $4.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKPast Featured Flavors
FeaturedCampfire S’more
$5.00/cookie member · $6.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKFeaturedStrawberry Rhubarb Pie
$5.00/cookie member · $6.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKFeaturedCarrot Cake
$5.00/cookie member · $6.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKFeaturedButterfetti Bliss
$5.00/cookie member · $6.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKFeaturedBrown Butter Tiramisu
$5.00/cookie member · $6.00/cookie regular
Member pricing locked
JOIN TO UNLOCKGive the Gift of Cookies
Know someone who deserves a monthly cookie surprise? Send them a gifted month — $30, one-time.